Back to Analyses

Cook Islands

Retail_Trading_Status

Allowed-Unregulated Unknown
Edit

Status Changed

Previous status: Allowed-UnRegulated

The primary difference between the two analyses lies in the assigned status and the nuanced interpretation of the regulatory environment for retail cryptocurrency trading in the Cook Islands. The previous analysis concluded with "Allowed-UnRegulated," while the new analysis determined the status to be "Gray-Zone." Justification for the differences: 1. **Interpretation of "Unregulated":** * The **previous analysis** interpreted the absence of specific prohibitions and the lack of a dedicated licensing regime for crypto exchanges as "Allowed-UnRegulated." This status emphasizes that individuals are not legally barred from trading, even if no specific rules govern the activity. * The **new analysis** takes this a step further. While agreeing that there's no outright ban, it uses "Gray-Zone" to better capture the ambiguity and the current legislative and regulatory focus. The term "Gray-Zone" implies not just a lack of regulation for retail trading, but an environment where the government's primary engagement with cryptocurrency is overwhelmingly focused on its illicit uses and recovery (via the Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023), rather than on creating a clear, permissive, or even a basic regulatory framework for legitimate retail activity. This focus on the negative aspects, coupled with the lack of positive regulatory development for retail traders, creates an uncertain environment. 2. **Emphasis on the Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023:** * The **previous analysis** correctly identifies the Bill's focus on combating financial crime and asset recovery, noting it doesn't constitute a regulatory framework for retail trading. * The **new analysis** delves deeper into the *implications* and *controversies* surrounding this Bill. It highlights the significant concerns raised by crypto experts and legal professionals regarding human rights, due process, privacy, and lack of consultation. This intense focus on a potentially punitive and far-reaching bill, without corresponding efforts to regulate or guide the retail market, contributes significantly to the "Gray-Zone" characterization. The legislative energy is directed towards control and seizure in specific circumstances, not towards fostering or clarifying the retail trading landscape. 3. **Inclusion of Broader Context and Recent Developments:** * The **new analysis** incorporates more recent information and a wider range of stakeholder perspectives concerning the Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill (e.g., criticisms from crypto experts, concerns from the Justice Minister, Ora Partners). It also mentions broader AML/CTF collaborations (e.g., with AUSTRAC) and separate, positive blockchain initiatives (Smart Trust platform). This paints a picture where the government is engaging with cryptocurrency and blockchain technology on multiple fronts, but its approach to retail trading remains undefined and overshadowed by its AML/CFT priorities. The positive blockchain initiatives are distinct from retail trading regulation. 4. **Nuance in Regulatory Attention:** * Both analyses note the FSC's warnings about unlicensed entities. However, the **new analysis** frames this within the broader context of a government primarily concerned with illicit activities. The warnings serve more as a caution against fraud in an unregulated space rather than an indication of an impending regulatory framework for legitimate retail platforms. * The **previous analysis** focuses more on the *absence* of licensing for crypto exchanges. The **new analysis** highlights that this absence, combined with the active pursuit of "tainted" crypto, creates an environment of uncertainty rather than simple non-regulation. 5. **Evolution of Understanding:** * The new analysis, being slightly later, benefits from more published discourse and debate surrounding the Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill, which seems to have intensified between April and June 2025 (based on the fictional dates, but reflecting real-world patterns where understanding evolves as bills are debated). This allows for a more refined assessment of the overall atmosphere for retail crypto activities. In essence, while both analyses agree on the factual absence of a specific ban or a dedicated retail crypto regulatory framework, the new analysis ("Gray-Zone") provides a more nuanced interpretation. It suggests that the current strong legislative and regulatory focus on AML/CFT and the controversial nature of the Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill create an environment of significant uncertainty and potential risk for retail traders, moving beyond simple "unregulation" to a more ambiguous and potentially precarious "gray zone." The government's actions are more reactive to perceived threats than proactive in establishing clear rules for ordinary retail participation.

Analysis ID
#566
Version
Latest
Created
2025-06-26 13:28
Workflow Stage
Live

Executive Summary

Retail cryptocurrency trading is allowed but unregulated in the Cook Islands as of April 12, 2025. The primary regulator, the Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC), focuses on AML/CFT compliance within existing regulated sectors and combating illicit uses of crypto. A key piece of legislation is the 'Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023,' which targets crypto assets linked to illicit activities rather than regulating retail trading. Therefore, no licensing framework exists for crypto exchanges or brokers targeting retail consumers.

Key Pillars

The primary regulator is the Cook Islands Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC). Core compliance requirements include Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Financing of Terrorism (AML/CFT) regulations, overseen by the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) and the FSC for its licensees. There is no licensing or registration requirement for cryptocurrency exchanges or brokers specifically.

Landmark Laws

The 'Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023' focuses on identifying, seizing, and forfeiting cryptocurrency linked to illicit activities. It was mentioned by the Cook Islands News on December 16, 2023. The bill allows for 'recovery agents' to use means including hacking to investigate and find cryptocurrency used for illegal purposes. It has extraterritorial effect.

Considerations

Cryptocurrencies are not explicitly classified. There is a lack of specific regulations for consumer protection, platform licensing, or operational standards tailored to the crypto sector for retail participants. A key concern is the illicit use of crypto, addressed by the 'Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023.'

Notes

A 2019 report suggested that crypto-related businesses might operate outside the scope of existing financial regulations. The 'Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023' has raised concerns about civil liberties, privacy, and due process. Trustee companies in the Cook Islands follow AML/CFT system guidelines and are supervised by the FSC.

Detailed Explanation

Retail cryptocurrency trading in the Cook Islands is currently categorized as 'Allowed-UnRegulated' as of April 12, 2025. This means that individuals are not legally prohibited from buying, selling, or holding cryptocurrencies. However, there is a lack of a specific regulatory framework governing cryptocurrency exchanges, brokers, or related services that target retail consumers. The Cook Islands Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) is the primary regulator for financial services, overseeing banks, insurers, money-changing businesses, trustee companies, and international companies. While the FSC issues warnings about unlicensed entities, particularly in the forex trading space (some falsely claiming FSC authorisation), it does not appear to license or specifically regulate cryptocurrency exchanges or platforms for retail trading purposes. The existing legislation administered by the FSC doesn't include specific provisions for digital assets in the context of retail trading platforms.

A 2019 report suggests that certain crypto-related businesses, like Crypto CFD brokerages, might operate outside the scope of existing financial regulations, which aligns with the current lack of a specific crypto regulatory regime. The 'Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023,' focuses on identifying, seizing, and forfeiting cryptocurrency linked to illicit activities, potentially involving extraterritorial actions. Although this demonstrates governmental awareness of cryptocurrency, it's designed to combat financial crime rather than regulate the retail trading market or license service providers for consumers. The bill allows for 'recovery agents' to investigate and seize cryptocurrency used for illegal means.

Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Financing of Terrorism (AML/CFT) regulations are in place in the Cook Islands, overseen by the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) and the FSC for its licensees. Licensed entities, such as trustee companies, are subject to KYC (Know Your Customer) and AML/CFT obligations. It is unclear how these AML/CFT requirements are specifically applied to standalone cryptocurrency exchanges or brokers that might serve Cook Islands residents, given the apparent lack of a licensing framework for such entities. Reputable trustee companies conduct Know Your Customer (KYC) and AML/CFT checks on settlors attempting to establish trusts. This requires Cook Islands Trust companies/firms to be licensed and supervised by the FSC and to follow AML/CFT system guidelines.

In summary, individuals can engage with cryptocurrencies, but this activity occurs in an environment lacking specific regulations for consumer protection, platform licensing, or operational standards tailored to the crypto sector for retail participants. The focus of authorities appears to be on AML/CFT compliance within already regulated sectors (like trust companies) and addressing illicit uses of crypto through specific initiatives like the Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill, rather than establishing a comprehensive framework for the retail crypto market. Forex trading companies, like Crypto Coin Vent, falsely claim authorization by the Cook Islands Financial Supervisory Commission, indicating potential risks associated with unregulated entities operating in the financial space.

Summary Points

Retail Cryptocurrency Trading Status in Cook Islands: Regulatory Analysis (April 12, 2025)

Disclaimer: This information is based on publicly available data and subject to change. Consult local experts for specific advice.

I. Overall Regulatory Status:

  • Allowed-Unregulated: Retail cryptocurrency trading (buying, selling, holding) is permitted but lacks specific regulatory oversight.

II. Key Regulatory Bodies:

  • Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC):
    • Primary regulator for financial services (banks, insurers, etc.).
    • Issues warnings about unlicensed entities, primarily in forex trading (some falsely claiming FSC authorization and using "crypto" in their names).
    • Role: Does not currently license or specifically regulate cryptocurrency exchanges or platforms for retail trading purposes. Existing legislation doesn't include specific provisions for digital assets in this context.
  • Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU):
    • Oversees Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Financing of Terrorism (AML/CFT) regulations.
    • Works in conjunction with the FSC for its licensees.

III. Important Legislation and Regulations:

  • Lack of Specific Crypto Regulations: No dedicated regulatory framework governs cryptocurrency exchanges, brokers, or related services specifically targeting retail consumers.
  • Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023:
    • Focuses on identifying, seizing, and forfeiting cryptocurrency linked to illicit activities ("tainted crypto").
    • Potentially involves extraterritorial actions (e.g., hacking).
    • Purpose: Combating financial crime involving crypto, not regulating the retail trading market.
  • AML/CFT Regulations:
    • In place and overseen by the FIU and FSC.
    • Licensed entities (e.g., trustee companies) are subject to KYC (Know Your Customer) and AML/CFT obligations.
    • Unclear Application: How these requirements apply to standalone crypto exchanges/brokers serving Cook Islands residents is uncertain due to the lack of a licensing framework.

IV. Requirements for Compliance:

  • For Licensed Entities (e.g., Trustee Companies):
    • KYC (Know Your Customer) procedures.
    • AML/CFT (Anti-Money Laundering/Counter-Financing of Terrorism) compliance.
  • For Crypto Exchanges/Brokers (Unclear):
    • Due to the lack of specific regulations, compliance requirements for crypto exchanges/brokers are not clearly defined.

V. Notable Restrictions or Limitations:

  • Lack of Consumer Protection: Absence of specific regulations for consumer protection in the crypto sector.
  • No Platform Licensing: No licensing requirements for cryptocurrency exchanges or platforms operating in the Cook Islands.
  • Operational Standards: No specific operational standards tailored to the crypto sector for retail participants.

VI. Recent Developments or Changes:

  • Introduction of the Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023: Highlights governmental awareness of cryptocurrency and its potential for illicit use.
  • Continued FSC Warnings: FSC continues to issue warnings about unlicensed entities, primarily in the forex trading space, some falsely claiming FSC authorization and using "crypto" in their names.

Full Analysis Report

Report on the Retail Trading Status of Cryptocurrencies in the Cook Islands

Date: 2025-06-26

Topic: Retail_Trading_Status

Description: Assess whether individual citizens and residents in the country are legally permitted to buy, sell, and hold cryptocurrencies. Detail the regulatory environment surrounding this activity (e.g., KYC/AML requirements imposed on platforms, general warnings issued).

1. Identified Status

Gray-Zone

2. Detailed Narrative Explanation

The status of retail cryptocurrency trading in the Cook Islands is best described as a "Gray-Zone." While there is no outright ban on individuals buying, selling, or holding cryptocurrencies, the regulatory landscape is not clearly defined for retail trading. Instead, the current focus of legislative efforts and regulatory attention is primarily on Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Counter-Terrorist Financing (CTF) aspects, particularly concerning the recovery of "tainted" cryptocurrencies linked to illicit activities.

The Cook Islands Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) is the primary regulatory body for financial services. While the FSC licenses and supervises financial institutions such as banks, insurers, money-changing and remittance businesses, and trustee companies, there is no specific licensing regime or set of regulations explicitly governing cryptocurrency exchanges or retail trading platforms for individual citizens. The FSC has issued public notices warning about entities falsely claiming to be licensed or regulated by them to offer cryptocurrency trading services. This indicates that while such services might be accessible, they are not necessarily operating under a specific Cook Islands regulatory framework for cryptocurrencies.

A significant development is the "Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023". This bill, currently under parliamentary review and subject to considerable debate, aims to establish a framework for the detection, investigation, seizure, and forfeiture of cryptocurrencies linked to criminal activities. The bill's focus is on combating money laundering, terrorism financing, and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. While this bill addresses cryptocurrencies, it does so from a law enforcement and asset recovery perspective rather than establishing a comprehensive regulatory framework for everyday retail trading. Concerns have been raised by various stakeholders, including crypto experts and legal professionals, regarding the bill's potential impact on human rights, due process, and privacy, as well as its extraterritorial reach. The drafting process and the alleged involvement of a foreign debt recovery firm have also been points of contention.

The Cook Islands Financial Intelligence Unit (CIFIU), which merged with the FSC in 2012, plays a role in combating financial crime and is involved in discussions and initiatives related to the illicit use of cryptocurrencies in the Pacific region. The CIFIU collaborates with international bodies like AUSTRAC to enhance its capabilities in detecting and disrupting financial crime, including those involving digital assets.

There is also an acknowledgment of the potential of blockchain technology. For instance, a project was announced to develop a 'Smart Trust platform' built on a blockchain, in conjunction with the Ministry of Finance and Economic Management (MFEM), aimed at modernizing the trust industry. This initiative suggests an openness to the underlying technology, though it doesn't directly translate to a regulated environment for retail crypto trading.

In summary, individuals in the Cook Islands are not explicitly prohibited from engaging in cryptocurrency trading. However, the lack of specific regulations for consumer protection, licensing of exchanges for retail purposes, and clear guidelines for individual traders places the activity in a gray zone. The current legislative focus is heavily skewed towards AML/CTF and the recovery of illicitly obtained crypto assets, rather than fostering a regulated retail trading environment. General financial laws and AML/CTF requirements would likely apply to any entities involved in financial transactions, including those involving cryptocurrencies, but a dedicated, clear framework for retail crypto trading is absent.

3. Specific, Relevant Text Excerpts

  • Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill 2023: "A new Bill that will enable Government to seize and forfeit cryptocurrency will be tabled in Parliament this week. Despite concerns from the crypto community, Teariki Olah, the founder of a local crypto enthusiast group, has welcomed the 2023 Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill." "According to its explanatory notes, the Bill aims to combat money laundering, financing of terrorism, financing of proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. The Bill focuses on the detection, investigation, seizure and forfeiture of cryptocurrency that is or represents the proceeds of proscribed conduct, which can be achieved through the process of civil forfeiture."
  • Concerns regarding the Tainted Cryptocurrency Recovery Bill: "There is growing concern over the Cook Islands dealings on a cryptocurrency bill before parliament which allegedly could be used to hack into systems around the world." "Industry members say there was a lack of consultation as this bill was drafted, leaving them very concerned. Stakeholders are urging a halt to the bill's progression, citing its potential far-reaching consequences." "A Cook Islands cryptocurrency expert is critical of a proposed law targeting tainted cryptocurrency, arguing it undermines human rights and doesn't address the real channels of money laundering."
  • Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) Warnings: "Crypto Coin Vent, a forex trading company, claims to be authorised and regulated by the Cook Islands Financial Supervisory Commission. This statement is false and misleading. Crypto Coin Vent has never been licensed or regulated by the Cook Islands Financial Supervisory Commission, nor has it ever applied to be." (Similar warnings have been issued for other entities like CSL Banco and Global FX Trade Markets).
  • Focus on AML/CTF: "Since last year's meeting in the Cook Islands, PFIC members have focused their efforts on combating transnational organised crime, corruption and child sexual exploitation. AUSTRAC has worked with FIUs to ensure they have the training and capabilities required to proactively identify and tackle these crimes. As well as ongoing themes such as money laundering, this year's meeting will also address emerging issues such as illicit use of cryptocurrency, new payment platforms, and gambling in the region."
  • Blockchain Initiatives: "The Smart Trust platform will enable Ora Partners to offer innovative digital technology to its clients and other trust businesses in the Cook Islands and overseas. It is being used as the pilot project for the development of a new blockchain ecosystem for the Cook Islands." "MFEM Financial Secretary Garth Henderson says: 'This highly innovative pilot project has the potential to create immense economic benefit for trust companies, banks, law firms, accounting firms, money managers and other related financial services firms. Once a new blockchain ecosystem is established, it will also open up opportunities for the wider Cook Islands economy and for Cook Islanders to be technology-based entrepreneurs competing on the world stage.'"

4. Direct, Accessible URL Links to Sources

  • Financial Supervisory Commission - Public Notices: https://www.fsc.gov.ck/public-notices/
  • Cook Islands News - Cook Islands to crack down on crypto with new Recovery Bill (December 13, 2023): https://www.cookislandsnews.com/internal/national/parliament/cook-islands-to-crack-down-on-crypto-with-new-recovery-bill/ (Note: While the direct article link provided by the search result might vary, the source is Cook Islands News)
  • AUSTRAC - AUSTRAC and Pacific financial intelligence units gather in Brisbane to tackle financial crime in the region (November 12, 2024 - Note: The year in the search result seems to be a typo and likely refers to an earlier date given the context of other articles): https://www.austrac.gov.au/news-and-media/media-releases/austrac-and-pacific-financial-intelligence-units-gather-brisbane-tackle-financial-crime-region (The actual meeting referenced as "last year's meeting in the Cook Islands" would have been in 2023). A more relevant link for the Cook Islands meeting: https://www.austrac.gov.au/news-and-media/media-releases/austrac-and-financial-intelligence-units-across-pacific-meet-cook-islands-further-fight-against-money-laundering (November 16, 2023)
  • Ora Partners - Ora Partners Kick-Starts Cook Islands First Blockchain Initiative: https://www.orapartners.com/ora-partners-kick-starts-cook-islands-first-blockchain-initiative/
  • RNZ - 'Not consulted': Cook Islands cryptocurrency bill 'reason for concern', justice minister says (April 23, 2024): https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/515065/not-consulted-cook-islands-cryptocurrency-bill-reason-for-concern-justice-minister-says
  • Cook Islands News - Proposed law on tainted cryptocurrency ‘terrible’ for human rights, says Cook Islands expert (May 8, 2024): https://www.cookislandsnews.com/national/parliament/proposed-law-on-tainted-cryptocurrency-terrible-for-human-rights-says-cook-islands-expert/
  • Cook Islands News - Considering the 2023 Tainted Cryptocurrency : Recovery Bill Civil liberties, privacy and due process (December 16, 2023): https://www.cookislandsnews.com/internal/national/parliament/considering-the-2023-tainted-cryptocurrency-recovery-bill-civil-liberties-privacy-and-due-process/
  • AUSTRAC - AUSTRAC and financial intelligence units across the Pacific meet in Cook Islands to further fight against money laundering (November 16, 2023): https://www.austrac.gov.au/news-and-media/media-releases/austrac-and-financial-intelligence-units-across-pacific-meet-cook-islands-further-fight-against-money-laundering
  • Islands Business - Government insists on value of crypto bill despite criticism (April 19, 2024): https://islandsbusiness.com/news-break/government-insists-on-value-of-crypto-bill-despite-criticism/
  • Shufti Pro - Pacific Financial Intelligence Unit Collaborates to Combat Money Laundering (November 21, 2023): https://shuftipro.com/news/pacific-financial-intelligence-unit-collaborates-to-combat-money-laundering/
  • Cook Islands News - Crypto Bill threatens anti-money laundering efforts: Ora Partners (April 26, 2024): https://www.cookislandsnews.com/business/finance/crypto-bill-threatens-anti-money-laundering-efforts-ora-partners/
  • Financial Supervisory Commission - Cook Islands: https://www.fsc.gov.ck/

Web Sources (13)

Sources discovered via web search grounding

Search queries used (6)
  • Cook Islands cryptocurrency regulation
  • Cook Islands crypto trading laws
  • Cook Islands AML/KYC cryptocurrency
  • Cook Islands Financial Supervisory Commission cryptocurrency
  • Cook Islands Ministry of Finance and Economic Management cryptocurrency
  • Cook Islands financial intelligence unit cryptocurrency
Source

Source

Source

Source

Source

Source

Source

Source

Source

Source

Source

Source

Source

Reviews

No reviews yet

Submit Review

Challenge: Disagree with the analysis | Approval: Confirm it's correct | Refinement: Suggest improvements