Madagascar
Retail_Trading_Status
- Analysis ID
- #224
- Version
- Archived
- Created
- 2025-04-13 08:00
- Run
- cfcea1fe...
- History
- View all versions
- Workflow Stage
- Live
Executive Summary
Retail cryptocurrency trading is banned in Madagascar due to official warnings from the Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM). The BCM has stated that cryptocurrencies lack legal tender status and has cautioned the public against their use due to risks like money laundering and financial instability. There is no regulatory framework permitting or overseeing cryptocurrency activities, although the BCM is participating in regional discussions and undertaking internal reflections on fintech. Some P2P trading may occur, but it operates outside the established legal and financial system.
Key Pillars
The primary regulator is the Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM). The BCM's approach is to prohibit retail cryptocurrency trading through warnings and directives, citing the lack of legal tender status and various risks. There are no licensing or registration requirements for cryptocurrency-related activities, as these activities are not regulated under existing Malagasy law.
Landmark Laws
The primary legal instrument affecting cryptocurrency is the Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM) Communiqué issued in October 2021. It states that cryptocurrencies are not legal tender, are not regulated by the BCM, and warns of the risks associated with cryptocurrencies.
Considerations
Cryptocurrencies do not have legal tender status in Madagascar. The BCM has warned the public about the risks associated with cryptocurrencies, including their potential use in illicit activities, financial risks stemming from high volatility, a lack of consumer protection, and the absence of legal recourse in cases of cyber-attacks or fraud. There are operational challenges, including the lack of a regulatory framework, which leads international exchanges to restrict services in Madagascar.
Notes
While retail cryptocurrency trading is banned, the Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM) is participating in regional discussions about potential regulation and undertaking internal reflections on fintech/sandboxes. Despite the ban, some peer-to-peer (P2P) trading may occur outside the legal and financial system. Proelium Law LLP lists Madagascar's status as "Undecided" but elaborates, stating, "No legal status for cryptocurrencies; There is no cryptocurrency regulation."
Detailed Explanation
Detailed Explanation
The retail cryptocurrency trading status in Madagascar is Banned, according to official communications from the Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM) and various legal and financial information sources. While no specific legislation explicitly prohibits cryptocurrency activities, the BCM has issued warnings and directives that effectively ban such activities for the general public. In October 2021, the BCM released a communiqué stating that cryptocurrencies are not issued or regulated by the BCM or any other monetary authority in Madagascar and do not have legal tender status. Furthermore, the BCM asserted that providers offering services related to cryptocurrency investment, marketing, or exchange are not regulated under existing Malagasy law. The BCM warned the public about the risks associated with cryptocurrencies, including their potential use in illicit activities like money laundering and terrorism financing, financial risks stemming from high volatility and speculation, a lack of consumer protection, and the absence of legal recourse in cases of cyber-attacks, fraud, or errors. The BCM's stance is based on Article 9 of the law governing its statutes, which grants it the exclusive privilege of issuing legal tender.
Although some sources indicate ongoing reflections within the BCM regarding virtual assets and fintech, including participation in ESAAMLG discussions about potential regulation, these discussions have not yet translated into any change in the BCM's prohibitive stance. Some sources suggest that within ESAAMLG, there is consensus that crypto should be regulated, not banned, but this does not reflect Malagasy law. International exchanges often list Madagascar as a country where services are restricted or unavailable due to the regulatory environment. While some peer-to-peer (P2P) trading may occur, it operates outside the legal and financial system and carries the risks highlighted by the BCM. A report by the Association of African Central Banks (AACB) mentions that the BCM is undertaking internal "reflections" on fintech and sandbox environments. John W Ffooks & Co (Legal Firm specializing in Francophone Africa) stated on April 28, 2022, that "Madagascar has still not adopted any laws or regulations on cryptocurrency" and refers to the BCM's official communiqué from October 5, 2021.
Therefore, based on the central bank's official warnings and the lack of any regulatory framework permitting or overseeing cryptocurrency activities, retail trading (buying, selling, holding) is considered banned for individuals in Madagascar.
Summary Points
Here's a bullet-point summary of the regulatory analysis report regarding Retail Cryptocurrency Trading Status in Madagascar:
I. Overall Regulatory Status:
- Banned: Retail cryptocurrency trading (buying, selling, holding) is effectively banned for individuals in Madagascar.
II. Key Regulatory Body:
- Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM) - Central Bank of Madagascar:
- Role: Primary authority on financial matters.
- Actions: Issued warnings and directives effectively prohibiting cryptocurrency activities for the general public.
- Mandate: Holds exclusive privilege of issuing legal tender (banknotes and coins).
- Stance: Cryptocurrencies lack legal tender status and are unregulated.
III. Important Legislation and Regulations:
- No specific cryptocurrency legislation exists.
- BCM Communiqué (October 2021):
- Cryptocurrencies are not issued or regulated by the BCM or any other monetary authority.
- Cryptocurrencies do not have legal tender status in Madagascar.
- Providers offering crypto services are not regulated under existing Malagasy law.
- Warns the public about risks associated with cryptocurrencies.
- Article 9 of the law governing BCM statutes: Grants BCM the exclusive privilege of issuing legal tender.
IV. Requirements for Compliance:
- Compliance is achieved by not engaging in retail cryptocurrency trading.
- No regulatory framework exists for legal cryptocurrency operations.
V. Notable Restrictions and Limitations:
- Prohibition of Retail Trading: Individuals are effectively prohibited from buying, selling, or holding cryptocurrencies.
- Lack of Legal Tender Status: Cryptocurrencies are not recognized as legal tender.
- Unregulated Service Providers: Cryptocurrency-related service providers operate outside the legal framework.
- Risks Highlighted by BCM:
- Potential use in illicit activities (money laundering, terrorism financing).
- Financial risks due to volatility and speculative nature.
- Lack of consumer protection.
- Absence of legal recourse in cases of fraud or cyber-attacks.
VI. Recent Developments and Changes:
- No changes to the prohibitive stance.
- Ongoing Reflections/Studies (BCM): Internal discussions and studies within the BCM regarding virtual assets and fintech are ongoing.
- Regional Discussions (ESAAMLG): Participation in regional discussions about potential regulation, including a consensus that crypto should be "regulated, not banned" within ESAAMLG member countries.
- Note: This reflects regional discussions, not current Malagasy law.
- International Exchange Restrictions: Many international exchanges restrict or do not offer services in Madagascar due to the regulatory environment.
- Peer-to-Peer (P2P) Trading: May occur outside the legal system, carrying significant risks.
Full Analysis Report
Full Analysis Report
Report: Retail Cryptocurrency Trading Status in Madagascar
Topic: Retail_Trading_Status
Description: Assessment of the legal permissibility for individual citizens and residents in Madagascar to buy, sell, and hold cryptocurrencies, including details on the regulatory environment.
1. Identified Status: Banned
2. Narrative Explanation:
The current status of retail cryptocurrency trading in Madagascar is Banned. This determination is based on official communications from the Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM), the country's central bank, and consistent reporting from legal and financial information sources.
While Madagascar has not enacted specific, comprehensive legislation explicitly detailing cryptocurrency prohibitions, the BCM has issued clear warnings and directives that effectively ban activities related to cryptocurrencies for the general public. In October 2021, the BCM released a communiqué addressing the emergence of cryptocurrencies. In this statement, the BCM explicitly noted that:
* Cryptocurrencies are not issued or regulated by the BCM or any other monetary authority in Madagascar.
* Cryptocurrencies do not have legal tender status within the country.
* Providers offering services related to cryptocurrency investment, marketing, or exchange are not regulated under existing Malagasy law.
The BCM warned the public about significant risks associated with cryptocurrencies, including:
* Use in illicit activities like money laundering and terrorism financing due to the potential for anonymity.
* Financial risks stemming from high volatility and speculative nature, potentially leading to significant losses for consumers.
* Lack of consumer protection, as unregulated exchange platforms bear no responsibility for losses.
* Absence of legal recourse in cases of cyber-attacks, fraud, or errors.
The BCM's stance is grounded in its mandate, particularly Article 9 of the law governing its statutes, which grants it the exclusive privilege of issuing legal tender banknotes and coins in Madagascar. By stating that cryptocurrencies lack legal tender status and are unregulated, and by highlighting the severe risks without providing any framework for legal operation, the BCM effectively prohibits their legitimate use and trading by the general public.
Although some sources indicate ongoing reflections or studies within the BCM regarding virtual assets and fintech, and participation in regional discussions about potential regulation (like those within ESAAMLG), these discussions have not yet translated into any change in the prohibitive stance communicated to the public. International exchanges often list Madagascar as a country where services are restricted or unavailable due to the regulatory environment. While some peer-to-peer (P2P) trading might occur, it operates outside the established legal and financial system and carries the risks highlighted by the BCM.
Therefore, based on the central bank's official warnings and the lack of any regulatory framework permitting or overseeing cryptocurrency activities, retail trading (buying, selling, holding) is considered banned for individuals in Madagascar.
3. Relevant Excerpts from Sources:
-
Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM) via Orange Actu Madagascar (October 5, 2021): "Selon la Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BFM), les cryptomonnaies [...] ne sont ni émises ni règlementées par BFM ou toute autre autorité monétaire et n'ont pas cours légal à Madagascar. Aussi, les prestataires exerçant des activités d'investissement, de commercialisation ou d'échange de cryptomonnaies ne sont pas règlementés dans le cadre de la législation en vigueur [...] la Banque Centrale de Madagascar met en garde le public sur les risques associés aux cryptomonnaies [...] L'absence de statut légal et de cadre règlementaire figure également parmi les risques associés aux cryptomonnaies les plus marquants."
(Summary: According to the BCM, cryptocurrencies are neither issued nor regulated by the BCM or any other monetary authority and do not have legal tender status in Madagascar. Service providers related to crypto are not regulated. The BCM warns the public of the risks, highlighting the absence of legal status and regulatory framework as a major risk.) -
John W Ffooks & Co (Legal Firm specializing in Francophone Africa) (April 28, 2022): "Madagascar has still not adopted any laws or regulations on cryptocurrency. [...] The last official communiqué of the Central Bank on cryptocurrency was dated 5 October 2021. In this communiqué, the Central Bank (i) confirms that cryptocurrencies are not regulated in Madagascar, (ii) warns the public of risks associated to cryptocurrencies and (iii) recommends the public to exercise caution when involved in cryptocurrency-related activities."
-
Proelium Law LLP (Cryptocurrency Regulation Tracker): Lists Madagascar's status as "Undecided" but elaborates: "No legal status for cryptocurrencies; There is no cryptocurrency regulation." (Note: While labeled "Undecided," the description aligns with an environment where activity is not legally sanctioned or regulated, effectively supporting the Banned/Prohibited practical status based on BCM warnings).
-
Ministère de l'Economie et des Finances, Madagascar (Reporting on ESAAMLG meeting, Sept 2022): Mentions participation in a public-private dialogue regarding virtual assets, including the need to implement new cryptocurrency regulations in ESAAMLG member countries, suggesting a recognition of the topic but not indicating a change in Madagascar's domestic stance. It notes a consensus among members that crypto should be "regulated, not banned," but this reflects a regional discussion outcome, not current Malagasy law.
4. Source URLs:
- BCM Communiqué Summary (Orange Actu Madagascar): https://actu.orange.mg/emergence-de-la-cryptomonnaie-la-bfm-met-en-garde/
- John W Ffooks & Co Analysis: https://www.jwflegal.com/news/francophone-africa-cryptocurrency-regulation/
- Proelium Law LLP Tracker: https://www.proeliumlaw.com/cryptocurrency-regulation-tracker/
- Ministère de l'Economie et des Finances (ESAAMLG Report): https://www.mef.gov.mg/contenus/activites/835
- Association of African Central Banks (AACB) Report (mentioning BCM reflections): https://www.aacb.org/sites/default/files/2022-07/AACB%20Annual%20Report%202021%20-%20English.pdf (Page 79 references "Reflections on these topics are ongoing within BFM" regarding Fintech/Sandbox)
**Report: Retail Cryptocurrency Trading Status in Madagascar**
**Topic:** Retail_Trading_Status
**Description:** Assessment of the legal permissibility for individual citizens and residents in Madagascar to buy, sell, and hold cryptocurrencies, including details on the regulatory environment.
**1. Identified Status:** **Banned**
**2. Narrative Explanation:**
The current status of retail cryptocurrency trading in Madagascar is **Banned**. This determination is based on official communications from the Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM), the country's central bank, and consistent reporting from legal and financial information sources.
While Madagascar has not enacted specific, comprehensive legislation explicitly detailing cryptocurrency prohibitions, the BCM has issued clear warnings and directives that effectively ban activities related to cryptocurrencies for the general public. In October 2021, the BCM released a communiqué addressing the emergence of cryptocurrencies. In this statement, the BCM explicitly noted that:
* Cryptocurrencies are not issued or regulated by the BCM or any other monetary authority in Madagascar.
* Cryptocurrencies do not have legal tender status within the country.
* Providers offering services related to cryptocurrency investment, marketing, or exchange are not regulated under existing Malagasy law.
The BCM warned the public about significant risks associated with cryptocurrencies, including:
* Use in illicit activities like money laundering and terrorism financing due to the potential for anonymity.
* Financial risks stemming from high volatility and speculative nature, potentially leading to significant losses for consumers.
* Lack of consumer protection, as unregulated exchange platforms bear no responsibility for losses.
* Absence of legal recourse in cases of cyber-attacks, fraud, or errors.
The BCM's stance is grounded in its mandate, particularly Article 9 of the law governing its statutes, which grants it the exclusive privilege of issuing legal tender banknotes and coins in Madagascar. By stating that cryptocurrencies lack legal tender status and are unregulated, and by highlighting the severe risks without providing any framework for legal operation, the BCM effectively prohibits their legitimate use and trading by the general public.
Although some sources indicate ongoing reflections or studies within the BCM regarding virtual assets and fintech, and participation in regional discussions about potential regulation (like those within ESAAMLG), these discussions have not yet translated into any change in the prohibitive stance communicated to the public. International exchanges often list Madagascar as a country where services are restricted or unavailable due to the regulatory environment. While some peer-to-peer (P2P) trading might occur, it operates outside the established legal and financial system and carries the risks highlighted by the BCM.
Therefore, based on the central bank's official warnings and the lack of any regulatory framework permitting or overseeing cryptocurrency activities, retail trading (buying, selling, holding) is considered banned for individuals in Madagascar.
**3. Relevant Excerpts from Sources:**
* **Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM) via Orange Actu Madagascar (October 5, 2021):** "Selon la Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BFM), les cryptomonnaies [...] ne sont ni émises ni règlementées par BFM ou toute autre autorité monétaire et n'ont pas cours légal à Madagascar. Aussi, les prestataires exerçant des activités d'investissement, de commercialisation ou d'échange de cryptomonnaies ne sont pas règlementés dans le cadre de la législation en vigueur [...] la Banque Centrale de Madagascar met en garde le public sur les risques associés aux cryptomonnaies [...] L'absence de statut légal et de cadre règlementaire figure également parmi les risques associés aux cryptomonnaies les plus marquants."
*(Summary: According to the BCM, cryptocurrencies are neither issued nor regulated by the BCM or any other monetary authority and do not have legal tender status in Madagascar. Service providers related to crypto are not regulated. The BCM warns the public of the risks, highlighting the absence of legal status and regulatory framework as a major risk.)*
* **John W Ffooks & Co (Legal Firm specializing in Francophone Africa) (April 28, 2022):** "Madagascar has still not adopted any laws or regulations on cryptocurrency. [...] The last official communiqué of the Central Bank on cryptocurrency was dated 5 October 2021. In this communiqué, the Central Bank (i) confirms that cryptocurrencies are not regulated in Madagascar, (ii) warns the public of risks associated to cryptocurrencies and (iii) recommends the public to exercise caution when involved in cryptocurrency-related activities."
* **Proelium Law LLP (Cryptocurrency Regulation Tracker):** Lists Madagascar's status as "Undecided" but elaborates: "No legal status for cryptocurrencies; There is no cryptocurrency regulation." *(Note: While labeled "Undecided," the description aligns with an environment where activity is not legally sanctioned or regulated, effectively supporting the Banned/Prohibited practical status based on BCM warnings).*
* **Ministère de l'Economie et des Finances, Madagascar (Reporting on ESAAMLG meeting, Sept 2022):** Mentions participation in a public-private dialogue regarding virtual assets, including the need to implement new cryptocurrency regulations in ESAAMLG member countries, suggesting a recognition of the topic but not indicating a change in Madagascar's domestic stance. It notes a consensus among members that crypto should be "regulated, not banned," but this reflects a regional discussion outcome, not current Malagasy law.
**4. Source URLs:**
* **BCM Communiqué Summary (Orange Actu Madagascar):** [https://actu.orange.mg/emergence-de-la-cryptomonnaie-la-bfm-met-en-garde/](https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAItnLj5tnaAzeNmeQ7ki3AAXi0kj9E5EmjPCOpP2NVui8OA38gdkycxPNv7_FPFVTKWmWmfghXPUVs4YY3ythWKEAqBoO8iPn6AxfoZnAKlZDbNV3eI3XomNQhD-nw3VEfK_BE713ZWrEUzuyGUZX3_DDLS4eJ1NQJB2UT-eWZZ)
* **John W Ffooks & Co Analysis:** [https://www.jwflegal.com/news/francophone-africa-cryptocurrency-regulation/](https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKiVab5-pDttrFHJwWL8Kit3cu_yDBdKB7En1RUIFQZLNZoEgvaLw4rnTyp7Kf9hMMwUNxgLGIJLpzKgpUYVFWmKw2tAXWJpcUYHo_dMIgEqnV7Iz8t8E-FzIr3tEhXZ12WerHy2BrVHZG-T3txDB_drlHEQZD_5qpsxS2O9WAvdHqzS8jZGXSmhA==)
* **Proelium Law LLP Tracker:** [https://www.proeliumlaw.com/cryptocurrency-regulation-tracker/](https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAI_tNsO-nSggKNrWLIpuNtP2Su0fb06eM857LqwOB4nbU6mPpznVpok3ZT1iaB4GU1Tv1FpIzLavMoBwsiCYMgloGXiChCnBR4rkDoLPEGJ4jmaZrNqFlx1NqvTMj6XuA4syeaN5sbWcDnFPZUs7r42)
* **Ministère de l'Economie et des Finances (ESAAMLG Report):** [https://www.mef.gov.mg/contenus/activites/835](https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJIEVz5bIukqLtXQWTttVsylSo0Lz0EZcZiFfXT5EzYGzARFUzMLaNdoffVEE6IZnzHOJugcYZBLmaOqUFK59Q4ZfhEmrb4X3XT7fu7bu322AHKOjmUQQCyfxS0Mb3x14iLR2G2yZkn40c2vNDpLxc=)
* **Association of African Central Banks (AACB) Report (mentioning BCM reflections):** [https://www.aacb.org/sites/default/files/2022-07/AACB%20Annual%20Report%202021%20-%20English.pdf](https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIuAFX52YjEHB11FI4FnDIWrAXfRUjNQgS0Rmj-lWv8S8gxnpjr0w19Cj3GXe9t1ZBG_6l-wJQit0vUICoK07M3ymbgrizsp-T_O-fhhPUZggJTqqEsuVMhqJsv7hOLf5SXtfW8nOSG8V0qGWAyFNBxGILiRMeiLSqPfnnqfsLg7hxNi1VUuS_OZXdbyB9XAZkxQvrwtGvBh4jyCruriwf_envF) (Page 79 references "Reflections on these topics are ongoing within BFM" regarding Fintech/Sandbox)
Web Sources (10)
Sources discovered via web search grounding
Search queries used (7)
- What is the legal status of retail cryptocurrency trading in Madagascar?
- Is cryptocurrency banned in Madagascar?
- Banque Centrale de Madagascar cryptocurrency statement
- Madagascar crypto regulation law
- Réglementation cryptomonnaie Madagascar
- Loi Madagascar cryptomonnaie
- Madagascar crypto trading allowed